When propaganda collidedes with public reality: ADC’s political theatre in Kebbi and the limits of manufactured popularity

8

By Ahmed Idris 

A political movement can dominate the headlines and still remain peripheral to the people’s aspirations. In Kebbi, the ADC must confront an uncomfortable democratic reality: publicity is not popularity, criticism is not an alternative, and political ambition is not a substitute for public confidence.

There is a fundamental distinction between occupying the political conversation and commanding the confidence of the electorate. The former can be purchased with publicity, amplified through political surrogates and sustained by an endless stream of press statements. The latter is considerably more difficult to manufacture. It must be earned through credibility, consistency, competence and a demonstrable understanding of the people’s aspirations.

This distinction appears to be escaping the African Democratic Congress (ADC) in Kebbi State, where its recent media offensive against Governor Nasir Idris, popularly known as Kauran Gwandu, raises a more consequential question than the opposition perhaps intended: is the ADC building a credible political alternative, or merely attempting to manufacture one through the repetitive mechanics of propaganda?

The difference is not semantic. It is the difference between a political movement preparing to govern and one desperately seeking to be noticed.

The ADC’s recent communication strategy appears to rest on a rather familiar opposition assumption: that sustained attacks on an incumbent will eventually translate into public dissatisfaction, and that public dissatisfaction, in turn, will automatically produce electoral acceptance. It is a seductive but fundamentally defective political calculation. Voters do not necessarily reward the loudest critic; they reward the candidate or political platform they consider most capable of improving their circumstances.

Indeed, the description of the ADC’s recent media campaign as a political flop is not simply an expression of partisan irritation. It points to a deeper weakness in opposition politics: the inability to distinguish between generating controversy and generating consent.

A press statement is not a manifesto. A media appearance is not a political movement. And the ability to identify the shortcomings of government does not, by itself, establish the competence to govern.

The opposition’s missing proposition

The ADC must answer a question that no amount of rhetorical aggression can permanently evade: what exactly is its alternative proposition for Kebbi?

Where is its comprehensive economic programme? What is its strategy for agricultural productivity, rural prosperity, youth employment, healthcare delivery, educational transformation and infrastructure development? How does it intend to strengthen security, attract investment and expand the state’s productive capacity?

More importantly, what distinguishes its proposed approach from the policies and interventions already being pursued by the incumbent administration?

These are not unreasonable demands. They are the minimum intellectual requirements of a political party seeking to displace an elected government.

Opposition politics is indispensable to democracy, but opposition without an alternative programme degenerates into political heckling. Its purpose should be to interrogate power, expose failures, propose better solutions and compel government to perform. It should not become an industry in which political relevance is measured by the number of accusations circulated in the media.

The ADC appears increasingly preoccupied with the latter.

The Malami question: political reinvention or ideological convenience?

More intriguing is the political reinvention of Abubakar Malami, SAN, whose emergence as a prominent figure in the ADC’s political calculations inevitably invites scrutiny.

Malami occupied one of the most consequential positions in the Federal Government for eight years as Attorney-General of the Federation and Minister of Justice under an APC-led administration. His tenure placed him at the centre of the country’s legal and political architecture, with access to the machinery, influence and privileges of federal power.

His subsequent movement into the ADC is, of course, a legitimate exercise of democratic freedom. Political realignment is neither unconstitutional nor inherently objectionable. But freedom of association does not confer immunity from political interrogation.

A politician who has enjoyed the advantages of a governing party for years cannot reasonably expect the electorate to suspend its memory when he changes political address. Political migration may change a party membership card; it does not automatically erase a public record.

The pertinent question is not whether Malami has the right to seek political power. He does. It is whether he can convincingly explain the ideological, philosophical and programmatic basis of his new political destination.

What precisely changed? The party, the political philosophy, the policy convictions or simply the calculations of ambition?

These are legitimate questions in a democracy, not acts of political persecution.

There is also a wider contradiction worth examining. If the APC was fundamentally incapable of delivering the kind of governance now being promised by its former high-ranking member, what was the position of those who occupied its highest corridors of authority? If, on the other hand, the party’s platform provided opportunities for meaningful public service, what explains the sudden political estrangement?

The electorate deserves more than convenient political amnesia. It deserves an intellectually coherent explanation.

Governance is a more persuasive argument than propaganda

Meanwhile, Governor Nasir Idris occupies a different political position. As an incumbent, he must be judged by the performance of his administration, not merely by the inadequacies of his opponents.

His interventions across education, healthcare, infrastructure, agriculture and workers’ welfare provide the policy areas through which his government should be assessed. These are sectors with direct implications for household welfare, economic opportunity and the long-term development prospects of Kebbi.

But there is an important distinction here: government achievements must be demonstrated, independently scrutinised and measured against public expectations. No administration should be above criticism, and no governor should mistake electoral victory for a permanent licence to govern without accountability.

Nevertheless, the opposition must confront the same standard it seeks to impose on the incumbent. If it demands evidence of performance, it must present evidence of preparedness. If it interrogates public expenditure, it must demonstrate fiscal understanding. If it criticises policy outcomes, it must offer better policy alternatives.

Political accountability cannot be a one-way instrument.

For Governor Idris, the most compelling response to opposition rhetoric is not counter-propaganda. It is the continued delivery of tangible public goods, transparent governance and a development agenda whose benefits can be felt beyond the confines of Government House.

The strongest defence of an administration is a visible improvement in the lives of its citizens.

The fallacy of manufactured popularity

There is an even more fundamental error in the ADC’s apparent political calculus: the assumption that media visibility is a reliable proxy for electoral strength.

It is not.

Political communication can shape perceptions, frame public debates and influence the salience of issues. But communication has limits. It cannot indefinitely substitute for lived experience. A carefully constructed narrative may dominate social media while failing to resonate in rural communities, markets, farms, schools and households where political choices are often shaped by the everyday realities of governance.

This is where propaganda encounters its most formidable adversary: empirical public experience.

A farmer is more concerned with the conditions of production and market access than the frequency of political press releases. A parent wants functional schools, not competing claims of political superiority. A civil servant is interested in the reliability of salaries and welfare provisions. A young graduate wants opportunities, not another round of partisan exchanges.

The electorate is not an empty vessel into which political actors can pour whatever narrative suits their ambitions. Citizens possess memories, interests, expectations and independent political judgement.

To underestimate this is to confuse media amplification with democratic consent.

Kebbi is bigger than individual ambition

Ultimately, the political contest in Kebbi should not be reduced to the personal ambitions of Malami, the electoral calculations of the ADC or the political survival of Governor Idris. The state is not a private estate, and its people are not political spectators waiting to applaud whichever faction produces the most dramatic headlines.

The people deserve a serious contest of ideas: competing development blueprints, credible economic propositions, measurable commitments and leaders prepared to submit themselves to public scrutiny.

The ADC is entitled to challenge the government. Indeed, a responsible opposition should do precisely that. But it must understand that the burden of proof becomes heavier when it seeks to replace an incumbent. It must demonstrate not merely why the government should be criticised, but why it should be trusted with power instead.

That is the difficult business of democratic politics.

Gov Nasir Idris
  1. Governor Idris, for his part, must not allow the comfort of incumbency to obscure the urgency of performance. His administration must consolidate its achievements, address legitimate grievances, deepen accountability and ensure that development reaches communities irrespective of political affiliation.

Ultimately, the electorate will determine which political narrative survives contact with reality.

The ADC may command microphones, press statements and an increasingly animated media ecosystem. Malami may possess political experience and the ambition to return to the centre of power. Governor Idris may have the institutional advantage of incumbency and an existing development record to defend.

But none of these, in isolation, constitutes an electoral mandate.

The central lesson is simple: propaganda can manufacture visibility, but it cannot manufacture credibility indefinitely. Political ambition can secure attention, but only public trust can sustain legitimacy.

Kebbi is not a laboratory for testing how many headlines can be generated from political hostility. It is a state of citizens whose democratic choices cannot be dictated by the volume of partisan noise.

The ADC must do more than oppose. It must persuade. Malami must do more than aspire. He must account for his political journey and articulate a convincing alternative. And Governor Idris must do more than celebrate incumbency. He must continue to justify the confidence placed in his administration.

In the final analysis, democracy is not a contest of decibels. It is a contest of credibility.

The microphones may belong to the politicians. The mandate belongs to the people.

Ahmad Idris is the Chief Press Secretary to the Executive Governor of Kebbi State.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here